We all know by now that Kourtney Kardashian married Blink-182 drummer Travis Barker in a secret (and not-so-legal) Las Vegas ceremony after a very short-lived engagement period. What we didn’t know was how the actual proposal went down and what the initial reactions from her family were like. But Hulu’s The Kardashians has cleared some of it up in its latest episode, including how Kendall Jenner defended Scott Disick amidst the happy news. Fans are not too happy with Jenner, though, as a result.

In the May 5 episode of the freshman series, it was revealed that the entire family was in on Travis Barker’s secret Santa Barbara proposal plans – even the spirit of the late Robert Kardashian, Sr. The only ones who were left in the dark were Scott Disick and his kids with Kourtney Kardashian. Her daughter, 9-year-old Penelope Disick, was noticeably upset when she found out on the phone, and the sisters were all discussing the delicate situation when Kendall Jenner decided to pointedly question if Kourtney had “sympathy” for the father of her kids at all – because she didn’t feel that was the case. Viewers seem to think the comments were bad form on Jenner’s part. One Twitter user reacted: