It’s safe to say that Marvel fans were certainly surprised by Elizabeth’s revelation. They quickly took to social media to share their reactions to the actress’ hilarious response, comparing it to Keke Palmer‘s iconic “Sorry to this Man” moment during her own polygraph test. 

One fan wrote, “Elizabeth Olsen took one look at John Krasinski’s photo and said ‘i don’t know that man’ even though they were in the same movie.” 

Another praised the filmmaking process, adding, “The fact that Elizabeth Olsen & John Krasinski filmed an entire scene together in #MultiverseOfMadness and never actually met each other is extraordinary. Wow, I love movie magic.” 

And a third fan, well, blamed it all on the Multiverse, writing, “Shes telling the truth, she never saw him. It was an Elizabeth Olsen variant who shot those scenes with John Krasinski (also a variant).” 

However, Elizabeth did get a chance to talk about some of her Marvel co-stars that she has met, including Benedict Cumberbatch, who she agreed looked “a bit” like an excited otter.  

She also discussed her Captain America: Civil War co-star Chris Evans and his love of tap dancing on set too, adding, “That’s one of the things I like about him.”