“You’re putting me on the spot! What am I gonna do? What’s it gonna be?” a nervous Garfield asked in a panic.

He continued, “I need something to come, I’m like drawing a blank! This is an unfair question to ask in a high pressure, high stakes environment.”

Finally, after some long, hard, consideration, Garfield offered up, “Meryl?”

“Meryl Streep! I love it!” Cox approved. “You could do Meryl Streep on ‘Snatch Game.’ I love it.”

Andrew said with a laugh, “Why not? Let’s give it a try. She’s hilarious.”

Check out E!’s adorable interview with Garfield above.