When The Kardashians premiered on April 14, some fans were surprised to see Tristan Thompson gracing their screens alongside Khloé Kardashian. The couple has been broken up since 2021, and the youngest Kardashian sister hasn’t spoken publicly about their situation since Thompson’s paternity scandal came to light. However, the scenes shown in the first episode of the new Hulu reality show were shot before it was known he had a love child, and that fact provided a little extra context for fans, who noticed that the NBA player had a peculiar reaction to Kim Kardashian making an unexpected discovery.

Kim Kardashian was outraged when an ad popped up on Saint’s Roblox game claiming to have new footage from her 20-year-old sex tape. Many fans weren’t watching her and Khloé Kardashian as they looked at the tablet, however. Instead, they witnessed what appeared to be panic flash across Tristan Thompson’s face, and many fans interpreted Thompson’s frantic expression as fear that his latest cheating scandal was about to be exposed. One TikTok user said the PTSD must have kicked in after he’d already been caught so many times before. She said he looked “so guilty”:

@icutyolawnduhh
♬ original sound – ICutYoLawnDuhh