Last month, the White Lotus actress was photographed wearing a massive rock on her ring finger, causing speculation that Jonathan—who she’s been linked to since 2018—had popped the question.

Though neither Sydney or the restauranteur has confirmed the engagement, a separate source told E! News on March 2, “She and Johnny refer to each other as fiancés. They’re very cute and happy together.”

Earlier this year, Sydney spoke to Cosmopolitan about wanting to keep her love life out of the limelight.